We help businesses stand out, so they significantly increase their chance of converting more leads

+ 0 %

Increase in conversion off a high base - Manufacturer

0 %

Increase on conversion rate - B2B Service Business

+ 0 %

Increase on leads with a simple 1 page UX/UI revamp - B2B

+ 0

Awards & mentions across 4 different industries since 2009

Need a strategy?
Let’s point you in
the right direction

14 Mar 25

What Causes Your Customer Acquisition Funnel to Underperform?

Irwin Hau | Digital Marketing

If you’re wondering why your customer acquisition funnel isn’t delivering, you’re definitely not alone. Plenty of businesses reach that frustrating stage where leads show up but just don’t convert, and they’re left scratching their heads about what to fix first.

Usually, it’s not just one thing. It could be fuzzy targeting, weak lead nurturing, or a hidden bottleneck blocking people from taking that final step. Let’s unpack the common pitfalls and what you can do to get your funnel firing again.

1) Targeting and Messaging That Misses The Mark

If you don’t have a laser focus on who you’re talking to, your funnel’s probably leaking leads like a sieve. You might think you know your audience, but if your message doesn’t hit their pain points or speak their language, they’ll bounce.

For example, I worked with a local home services business last year whose ads were way too generic—something like “We do cleaning, gardening, and more!” Not exactly gripping, right? Once we got specific—targeting busy parents in Melbourne’s suburbs, highlighting “time-saving, trustworthy help you can rely on”—their conversion rate jumped 40% in just two months.

Key things to check here:

Do you really know your ideal customer’s problems?
Is your value clear and compelling from the first touchpoint?
Are you addressing why they should pick you over the competition?

2) Stuck With One Lead Gen Channel? Time To Mix It Up

Relying on a single lead source is like putting all your eggs in one basket. If Facebook Ads aren’t delivering, don’t just stare at the dashboard hoping for better results. Test other avenues.

Try combining:

SEO to catch people actively searching
Referral programs to leverage happy customers
Paid ads on LinkedIn or Google for specific industries
Social media content that educates and builds trust

Low-quality leads are a waste of time and money. Focus on channels that bring in people who actually want what you offer.

3) Lead Nurturing Doesn’t Have To Be Complicated—But It Can’t Be Lazy

Once someone’s in your funnel, you gotta keep them interested. Sending the same generic email to every lead? That’s a fast track to the unsubscribe button.

Use automation tools like ActiveCampaign or HubSpot to segment leads by behaviour—maybe they downloaded a guide but didn’t book a call, or they clicked a pricing page but didn’t convert. Then send relevant, timely follow-ups.

Things like:

Helpful tips related to their interest
Special offers based on their stage
Success stories from similar customers

This keeps you top of mind and builds trust.

4) Watch Out For Conversion Roadblocks

Sometimes prospects drop off at the same stage—say, the checkout or enquiry form. That’s a red flag.

Common hiccups:

Too many form fields
Confusing or long processes
Lack of clear CTAs or next steps

I once saw a client with a checkout page that asked for way too much info upfront. After cutting it back to just essentials, their sales jumped 25%.

Use tools like Hotjar or Google Analytics to track where people exit. Fix those leaks.

5) Data Isn’t Just For Nerds—It’s Your Best Friend

If you’re flying blind, you won’t know what’s broken. Track metrics like:

Click-through rates on emails and ads
Conversion rates at every funnel stage
Bounce rates on landing pages

Then test changes, like tweaking headlines or button colours. A/B testing might sound fancy, but it’s just trying two versions to see which wins.

Simple changes can make a big difference—like changing a button from “Submit” to “Get My Free Quote” can nudge more people over the line.

6) Don’t Forget The Customers You Already Have

Sometimes businesses get so obsessed with new leads, they forget about the ones they’ve got. Customer retention and upselling are part of the funnel too.

Think:

Personalised follow-ups after purchase
Loyalty programs or discounts
Targeted offers for complementary products or services

Happy customers come back and tell their mates, which means more leads without extra spend.

7) Sales and Marketing Need To Play Nice

When sales and marketing aren’t aligned, leads get lost—like tossing a hot potato and hoping it doesn’t drop.

Get both teams talking regularly, sharing lead info, and agreeing on what a “qualified lead” looks like. That way, marketing’s efforts don’t go to waste, and sales has better chances of closing deals.

Conclusion

Look—this stuff works, but only if you actually do the work to understand what’s going wrong and fix it. No magic tricks here, just rolling up your sleeves and digging in.

How are you tracking your funnel performance right now? What’s the one thing you reckon is the biggest leak?

Call us curious cats...